Episode 63: More Reviews Won't Get You #1 on Google Maps. This Will.

Episode overview

If a competitor has hundreds or even thousands more Google reviews than you, it's easy to think you'll never catch them on the map. But the most reviews isn't what decides who gets the top three spots.

In this episode of the Marketing Domination Podcast, Sean Garner walks through the three things Google says it looks at for local results: relevance, distance and prominence. In plain English, do you do what they searched for, are you close to them, and do people trust you?

Sean shares how one of SGC's plumbing clients got to number one in a big city ahead of competitors with more than twice their reviews, why being number one at your own shop doesn't tell you much, why the pace of your reviews matters more than the total, and when a second location makes sense.

The one thing to remember: Google doesn't reward the most reviews. It rewards the business it trusts most.

Key moments

How a plumber beat competitors with twice the reviews. Half Moon Plumbing couldn't break into the big city next door. On a 25-mile map grid they averaged around the 16th spot. Today they average 2.1, ahead of competitors with more than twice as many reviews. They didn't win by having the most reviews. They won because Google trusts them most.

The map isn't a popularity contest. Most owners think the business with the most reviews wins, so they give up. You still need reviews, but Google looks at more than that.

What Google actually ranks. Google's own help page says local results come down to relevance, distance and prominence. In the Search Atlas ranking factor data, how well the profile is built out weighs the most for both home service and medical businesses, followed by the main category. Review count weighs less than both.

Relevance: does Google understand what you do? Your main category should match your main money service. An HVAC company listed as "contractor" or a med spa listed as "beauty salon" confuses Google. Your website should have a page for every service you list on your profile, and the profile needs regular photos, posts and review replies.

Distance: how far your reach really goes. You'll always rank strongest near your address, so checking from your own office gives you a false read. Search your main service from 5, 10 and 15 miles out to see where you drop off. The more competition and the denser the area, the smaller your circle.

Trust: why review pace beats review count. Compare your last 90 days of reviews to the top three on the map, not your total. A business with 300 reviews that gets 20 a month looks more alive than one with 600 that hasn't gotten a review in months. Reply to every review.

When a second location makes sense. A real second location can win you another part of the map, but only once you're getting reviews consistently. Virtual offices don't count, and a new profile without review velocity just creates more work. Sean also shares when a second profile at your current address can make sense: when you offer two very different services that need different primary categories, like Half Moon's plumbing and septic.

Your map check. Search your main service plus "near me" from your shop, then from farther out, and compare the businesses beating you on main category, reviews in the last 90 days and reply rate.

Wrap up. Google doesn't reward the most reviews. It rewards the business it trusts most. Next episode: clicks don't pay the bills, booked appointments do.

Resources mentioned

Want to know exactly where you show up on the map?

If you ran the map check and you're not sure what's holding you back, schedule a call with us. We'll pull up how you show up across your whole service area, not just at your shop, and show you what to fix first.

Transcript

Sean (00:00)

One of our home service clients is number one on a map pack in a big city ahead of two competitors that have twice as many Google reviews than So if the most reviews always won, that wouldn't be possible, right? So today I'm gonna show you what actually decides who gets those top three spots on Google Maps and why you might be invisible just two miles from your own shop. Welcome to the Marketing Domination Podcast. My name's Sean Garner, and this show is for local service business owners. And every week I teach you exactly what needs to be working in your marketing in plain English

Sean (00:31)

with no tech jargon so you can grow your business without having to become a marketing expert. So let's get into So one of our home service clients is Half Moon Plumbing. And when we first started working with them a couple of years ago, they're already doing pretty well in the suburb that they were based out of, but they were struggling to break into the larger city that they were next to. And it seemed like no matter what they did, they couldn't get past. I think the best they were ever doing was like the 16th position. And you know, if you're not in the top three positions, especially in the Map Pack, practically invisible. And it could be frustrating whenever you see that because

Sean (01:03)

the competitor That were outranking them had two to three times the amount of reviews that they did. And after just working with them for six months, we were able to take them to an average of the top three in a 25-mile radius. And in most areas, it was the second or the first position in just six months. And we did this not because we all sudden tripled the reviews or anything like that, because this is what I want you to understand. They didn't win by having the most reviews. views, they won because Google started trusting them the most.

Sean (01:34)

So if you've ever looked at your competition that's got hundreds or even thousands, maybe more reviews than you, and you thought, man, I'm never gonna catch them, this next part is gonna change how you see the Google Map listings. See, I think a lot of small business owners think that the Map Pack is just a popularity contest, that the business that has the most reviews wins. And so if they're not able to catch with their competition, or maybe their competition is so far ahead, they don't even try. But what I want you to know is that even though reviews are important, I don't want you to think, wait, wait, wait, we don't need to get reviews. No, you do need to get reviews, but there's actually several other ranking factors that Google looks at.

Sean (02:10)

And so you don't have to. My team and I actually dork out on this kind of stuff. And we have learned that Google, guess what? They actually tell you what they look at on their own help pages. It says that local results really come to three things: relevance, distance, and prominence. In plain English there, do you do what they searched for? Are you close to them? And do people trust you? And all of this is backed up by data. Search Atlas is the SEO platform that we use, and they actually have a ranking case factor study across tens of thousands of Google business Profile. And out of 13 different factors, here's how they weigh for home service Business and medical Business.

Sean (02:48)

So for how well your profile is built out, that accounts for 96% of the ranking factors for home services. And guess what? A hundred percent. For medical. That's the biggest factor for how you show up in Google Map Pack listing is how well your profile is built out. can't tell you how many audits we do whenever somebody first reaches out to us and their account isn't even accurate and the information on there is wrong or it's just not fully optimized. The main category for your Google Business profile in the home service niche accounts for 72%.

Sean (03:21)

And in the medical niche, it accounts for 75% your overall. overall rankings. Review counts in home services count for 58%. And in the medical niche, they count for 49%. Photos is 53% and 55. So that's pretty close and pretty consistent. But your name, address, and phone number matching everywhere, only accounts for 50% of your rankings online. So if you think about this, the two biggest factors aren't even reviews at all. They're how well your profile is built and whether Google knows exactly what you do. So business owners will often say, man, Mike, my competitor has a thousand more reviews than me. Should I even try? Yes, absolutely. But you don't have to always catch their total.

Sean (04:01)

What you have to do is beat their pace. Our clients often outrank their competitors that have hundreds or even thousands of more reviews than them because of this review velocity. They might not be able to catch them on the total, especially if you're a new business competing against somebody that's been in business for decades longer. but you can beat them by outpacing them with the effort that you put in with review velocity. So let's break those three things down that Google is weighing. And the first one is where most Business quietly lose before they even get in a review.

Sean (04:36)

So the first thing, does Google understand what you do? This is relevance. What should be happening is when you look at your main profile, your Google Business Profile main category, it should match the main service that you perform. Your services are listed out, and each one of the subservices that you perform has a page for those things connected on the website that it's connected to. So how you should look at it is look at Your Google Business Profile and look at the primary category.

Sean (05:07)

A big common mistake that I see is like, let's say you're an HVAC company. Well, your main category is set as like contractor. Well, you might be a contractor, but the main thing you do is an HVAC company. Or if you're a medical spa, I see this all the time and it's hurting rankings. They have their primary category set. As beauty salon. So Google isn't exactly sure what to show, like what you should be showing up for. Remember, we just looked at the stats. The main category is one of the biggest levers for your whole Google Business Profile ranking.

Sean (05:40)

The set second only to how complete the profile is. So your Google Business profile isn't a set and forget. It's not like, yeah, I set that up when I launched my business and I get a few reviews for it. That isn't how it works. We should always be posting photos. Doing posts and I'm responding to all the reviews to show Google that we are an active real business. One question that I also get when it comes to this is Does your website actually affect your Map Pack rankings? Yes, absolutely.

Sean (06:10)

a couple of things. One, you need to make sure that your Google Business profile has the right what for one, the right website connected to it. One of the most common mistakes I see with business owners is they have the non-HTTPS version listed, or they'll have one of the things that blew my mind. The other day when we were doing an audit, is a business owner actually had a space whenever somebody was like copying and pasting it into the Google Business Profile. They had a space in there, so it looked right when you were visually looking at it. But when you tried to click it, it was broken because there was a space

Sean (06:41)

that had gotten pasted in there. So the website actually does matter. But this is what most business owners don't know it's not just about what website is linked on there, but whenever you are listing the services and the subcategories on On your Google business profile, you need to make sure that you have a page for each service that you are telling Google that you provide. So if you let's say you are a home service business that offers multiple different things and multiple different subservices, each thing that you list on your Google business profile needs to have a page on your website about that.

Sean (07:16)

because remember, it's about proving, SEO is about proving and being clear to Google and all of these AI tools. What it is you actually do. And so the map and your SEO are not two separate things. They should be working together. Now, the second factor is one that almost no one ever explains to business owners, and it's why you can be number one at your own shop and then completely invisible just 10 minutes away. So, number two is how close are you? This is proximity or distance.

Sean (07:46)

What should be happening is you should rank strongest near your address. And you need to have realistic expectations about how far that reach actually goes. This is how to tell if it isn't. I want you to search your main service from your business location and then search for it five miles out, 10, 15 miles out, or even ask a friend across town to. Search for it and then screenshot it because where you are at when you perform that search is a ranking factor. We obviously, as SEOs and marketing agencies, have tools that do this.

Sean (08:18)

There's ones that you guys can get. there's a free one. I I say it's free. You might have to pay for the upgraded version. but it is GMB everywhere. It's a great way where you can kind of actually see map pen listings of where you're ranking in certain spots of the town. Because a lot of business owners have false security of thinking that they're doing better than they really are. Are because they will check their rankings when they're at the office and be like, we're ranking number one for med spa near me or functional medicine provider or plumber or HVAC company because they're looking at it from the business.

Sean (08:49)

To me, it should be a bigger red flag if you look at your service. In your office, and you're not ranking number one. because being number one at your office, that is normal because again, you are closest to that. If you're looking for a, HVAC company near me, and you are the nearest one, of course, it's going to show you. what we see across our clients on our map scans is we like to look at the competitive service area across a big metro area because that will start to show us maybe competitors that own very small areas.

Sean (09:20)

or it can show us where we might want to put more of a focus on it. If you have a really strong dominant brand, it can reach a lot further. We we try to tell people that you should have a realistic expectations of you should at least want to own your area 10 miles out. Again, it depends on how competitive the market is and how. condensed the area is, it's gonna be a lot easier to rank 10 miles out from your facility in Tulsa, Oklahoma than it is, you know, Miami, Florida. other things to know is that niche niche services that have little competition,

Sean (09:53)

you can win the whole map pack. We've got one of our garage door companies in Indiana that we've got them ranking for like a 30 mile radius number one for garage door repair, just because of how dominant they are compared to the competition. So You know, if there's more competition, it's more of a densely populated area, the more difficult it is going to be to rank in a bigger circle.

Sean (10:41)

So we've talked about the first two ranking factors, right? It's gonna be how accurate your profile is and prominence. And the third one is where the reviews live. This is the one where you can start winning this week, no matter how far behind you are. it is number three: Does Google trust you? This is prominence. This is your reviews. This is what should be happening in your business. You are getting new reviews every single week. You reply to them, and the rest of the internet. Backs you up. This is how to tell if

Sean (11:11)

it isn't. Compare your last 90 days of reviews to your top three competitors in the app. Not just your total reviews, but your recent ones. that plugin that I was mentioning earlier, GMB everywhere. Think you gotta do this? I think this is part of the paid version of it. We can actually see something that's called review velocity, and you can track how quickly you are getting new reviews based upon your competition. Because still, total reviews still help, but how many. You're getting tells Google that people are choosing you this month, not five years ago. a business with 300 reviews that gets 20 a month

Sean (11:44)

looks more alive than a business with 600 that hasn't gotten a review for several months. One of our clients, a pest control company out in California, they actually went from 68 new reviews in one 90-day stretch to 166 the next, and that caused their profile. To jump up to ranking like 16 in their area up to the top five just by that review velocity. They didn't start outranking because they had more reviews, but because the pacing that they did, that started moving the needle.

Sean (12:16)

The other thing that you want to make sure that you're doing is to again show this proof and trust to Google is reply to every review. Our clients, we try to set this up for them to where we have always a 100% reply rate. This is really important. Just again, show Google that you are active. So one of the questions I get from Business whenever they start, we start working with them is well, how many reviews do I need to get to be able to start ranking the top three? There's not really a magic number. It depends on who you're up against, what they're doing, how many reviews they're getting. So you should look at the top three in your area, see how fast they're getting reviews,

Sean (12:53)

and then try to outpace them. Even if you can't catch the total because maybe you're a newer business, what can you do to get more reviews at a faster velocity than your competition? will say the magic number that this is very broad against dozens of markets and a lot of different Industries, the number I always tell clients to shoot for is 100. When you get to triple digits, I've Sean Google starts taking you a lot more seriously. even whenever you're against Business that have hundreds or thousands of reviews, you got to get to that triple digit number as quickly as possible. Because if you have gotten to that number,

Sean (13:27)

you've done some things, right? In the eyes of Google, they're gonna trust you a lot more because of the amount. But again, there's some industries that we work with, like especially like a lot of the home services. they'll have thousands of reviews on their competition. So that review velocity still is the most important thing. Now there's one more lever, and this is how some of the biggest players in the industry are taking over more than just one part of the map, and it is this: a bonus location. So step right here, I will say, is not for everyone, but if you want to be able to win the map pack in an area that's further away

Sean (14:03)

from your current office location, a real second location is how you can start winning other areas of the map. We've actually done this with multiple of our clients to where they are actually owning the the number one and number two spot on the map pack because all of their grids are starting to overlap. So I will say though it does have to be A real location. You can't use things like virtual offices and stuff like that, but you can use suite numbers, and it may make sense

Sean (14:34)

to open up a second location at your current location, and I'll explain that here in just a second. So, one of the the the most common questions I get with this is when should you open up a second location? I will say this: you should only consider opening up a second Google Business Profile location. Yes. You are already getting consistent reviews at your primary location, or you're wanting to test a market in a secondary location, because opening up another Google business profile in itself is not going to help you start ranking

Sean (15:07)

instantly, especially if you're not consistently getting reviews. If you're not having success with that review velocity, opening up a Google Business profile is a second location, is just going to hurt you. However, if you are doing good. With that review velocity, but you're still in a highly competitive market, then getting that other location is a great idea because you can start splitting those reviews up and start taking over other pins in the market. We've Sean this happen a lot with several of our clients as they start opening up these secondary, third, fourth locations across the state that they're in. They start dominating the entire map pack as they just start splitting over reviews. They'll own one area,

Sean (15:44)

then they'll go open up another one and start funneling over reviews to that. Now, here's one thing I haven't heard anyone talk about when it comes to open up second locations, is sometimes it may make sense to open up a second location at your current location. And so this is actually something that we've Sean with one of our clients. Is remember at the very first of this, we talked about the primary ranking factor is profile category and completeness. So we had one of our clients, it was it was actually half moon plumbing, that they obviously were ranking number one

Sean (16:16)

in their city and they had just to show you how important the primary category is, they were ranking number one for all things plumbing related. They do plumbing, septic, and electrical. But Even though they do septic services, they have septic listed as a subservice on their Google Business profile. We've got the website optimized for that. They're ranking well in the SERPs for Septic. They weren't ranking in the Map Pack. And the companies that were ranking the top three in the Map Pack only had a couple dozen, or maybe I think one had a hundred or so reviews when they had thousands. So why was that? Well, came down to again,

Sean (16:51)

primary category. So what we actually did with them is we opened up Another location at their same location, and we made that primary category be septic. So at their main HQ, they will have a primary category of plumbing, and that's the main plumbing Google business profile. Then they have another biz building out back that that was a different address and a different suite number, even though it's like in the same parking lot. And we made that primary category be a different service category, which was septic service.

Sean (17:22)

Just by doing that and throwing a few. extra reviews its way we instantly started ranking the top three map pack in that service area beating out those other people and even beating ourselves in that area because of the primary category. So if you own a building or and we've actually even done this with our medical clinic where we've got Wellspot Functional Medicine and Wellspot IV out of the same one. We just created a subsuite for it. That's where you could open up another Google business profile location at your current location if the primary category needs to be different because you do have two very different categories

Sean (17:57)

that you're trying to rank for but again only consider opening up other locations if you have the review velocity to back that up because if not you're just gonna be creating more work for yourself so How do you find out exactly where you stand this week without paying anybody anything? These are your action steps of the week. So number one, what I want you to do is I want you to do a map check. So I want you to search your main service area plus near me from your business location and write down the top three.

Sean (18:27)

Then I want you to do the same thing from like five miles out, 10 miles out, 15 miles out, you know, whatever makes sense and is relevant your location. Then for the Business beating you. I want you to compare these three things, their main category, how many reviews they've got in the last 90 days, and whether or not they're actually replying to them. Whichever of those three they can beat you on, that's where the work is gonna be for you. Like we talked about with Half Moon Plumbing, and we've Sean this with several of our clients, they don't always win because they have the most reviews.

Sean (18:58)

They win because Google understood exactly what they do and they never stopped building their trust. Remember, Google doesn't always just reward their most reviews. It rewards the business it trusts the most. So do the map check this week to see exactly where you rank. And if you want us to even do that for you to show you exactly where you rank, not just at shop, but your entire online presence, schedule a call with me, go to seangarner.co and book a call with me. I'm gonna do a complete deep dive audit on all of your marketing, your SEOs, show you exactly where you are ranking so you know exactly what you need to do so your business can grow and you can dominate online.

Sean (19:38)

Now, in our next episode, we are going to learn that guess what? Clicks don't pay the bills, booked appointments due. So you're gonna wanna check that one out so you can see exactly what you need to do to make sure that those clicks turn into customers. Have an awesome day and we'll see you on the next one.

Sean Garner

Most small business owners are overwhelmed and confused about how to market their business so that it grows and stands out from the competition.

At Sean Garner Consulting, we build, fill, and optimize sales funnels with storytelling marketing to get you more customers and leads online and be seen as the clear leader in your industry.

Discover what's wrong with your marketing & Take the FREE Assessment HERE

https://www.seangarner.co/
Next
Next

Episode 62: Your Phone Stopped Ringing. Here's What Probably Happened.